Should I Offer Buyer-Agent Compensation When I List in Naples?

Should I Offer Buyer-Agent Compensation When I List in Naples?

by Magdevys “Maggie” Rodriguez       November 19, 2026

One of the first questions I get at a listing appointment now is, “Do I still have to pay the buyer’s agent?” The short answer: no, it isn’t automatic anymore. As a Naples seller, buyer agent compensation is your choice. You can offer it, leave it to negotiation, or offer help with the buyer’s closing costs instead. Whatever you choose should be decided with your listing agent, in writing, before the house goes on the market. Here is how I walk my sellers through it.

If you are just starting to plan your sale, my guide to selling in Naples covers the full process. This post is only about the buyer-agent question.

What changed, and what didn’t

New practice rules from the National Association of REALTORS® settlement took effect on August 17, 2024. According to NAR’s guide for home sellers:

  • You still have the choice. You can offer compensation to the buyer’s broker as a way to market your home, but you don’t have to.
  • Not on the MLS. An offer of compensation can’t be posted on the Multiple Listing Service. It can be shared off the MLS, through flyers, websites, social media or a phone call or email between agents.
  • Your written approval comes first. Your listing agent has to disclose any payment to a buyer’s broker to you in writing, with the amount or rate, and get your approval before offering or paying it.
  • Concessions are different. You can still offer buyer concessions on the MLS, such as help with the buyer’s closing costs.

What didn’t change: commissions are fully negotiable and not set by law.

Why buyers care: their side of the table

Since the settlement, buyers working with an agent who uses the MLS sign a written agreement before touring a home. NAR explains that the agreement has to state the agent’s compensation in clear terms, like a flat fee or a percentage, and the agent can’t be paid more than that amount from any source.

So every buyer who walks into your home already knows what they owe their own agent. If you don’t cover any of it, they pay it out of pocket on top of the down payment and closing costs, or they ask for it in their offer. For buyers with plenty of cash, that’s no problem. For first-time buyers and buyers using low-down-payment loans, it can decide whether they can make an offer at all.

Your three main options

  1. Offer compensation up front. You approve an amount or a flat fee before listing, and I share it with buyers’ agents off the MLS. This keeps the most buyers in play from day one.
  2. Don’t offer, and negotiate in the offer. You list with no offer of compensation and decide offer by offer if a buyer asks for help. This keeps your options open, but some buyers may pass on your home if they can’t cover their agent’s fee.
  3. Offer a closing-cost concession instead. A seller concession goes toward the buyer’s closing costs and can be shown on the MLS. The buyer’s lender sets limits on how much a seller can contribute, so the buyer’s loan type matters.

NAR’s consumer guide on offers of compensation also notes you don’t have to advertise an offer if you make one. You can keep it to negotiations.

Put it on your net sheet before you decide

Any buyer-agent compensation or concession comes out of your proceeds, so I run it on a net sheet before you sign anything. In Collier County, the seller typically pays the documentary stamp tax on the deed (70 cents per $100 of the price, under section 201.02 of the Florida Statutes) and the commission. Here, the owner’s title policy and title fees are usually not a seller cost. If you are selling in Lee County or another county, plan on also paying the owner’s title policy and the title fees.

You can try the numbers yourself with my net proceeds calculator, then we compare a few versions side by side: no offer, an offer up front and a concession.

How I help you decide

  • Look at who your buyer is likely to be. A starter home may draw more first-time and low-down-payment buyers than a large estate home, and those buyers often have less cash left after closing.
  • Check the competition. I look at how similar active listings near you are handling it, so your home isn’t the one buyers skip.
  • Get it in writing. Whatever you choose goes into the listing agreement, so there are no surprises.
  • Revisit it with the showing feedback. If showings are slow in the first two or three weeks, we look at price, condition and terms together, including this one.

More common questions are answered on my seller FAQ page.

Featured home: 4442 18th Ave SW

One of my listings in Golden Gate City, 4442 18th Ave SW, is a remodeled pool home offered at $665,000 with no HOA:

  • A heated saltwater pool under the screen, a covered lanai, an outdoor kitchen and a dry bar
  • An island kitchen with quartz countertops, wood cabinetry, stainless appliances and a wine cooler
  • A converted garage guest suite with its own bedroom, bath and kitchenette
  • An air-conditioned outbuilding, a metal roof and a fully fenced 0.23 acre lot

See the photos on the 4442 18th Ave SW listing page, or call me for a private showing.

Do Naples sellers still have to pay the buyer’s agent?
No. Since August 17, 2024, offering compensation to a buyer’s agent is optional. You can offer it, negotiate it in an offer or offer a closing-cost concession instead. Your listing agent needs your written approval, with the amount or rate, before offering or paying anything.

Can buyer agent compensation be shown on the MLS?
No. Offers of compensation can’t be posted on the MLS. They can be shared off the MLS, for example on flyers, websites, social media or directly between agents. Seller concessions toward the buyer’s closing costs can still be shown on the MLS.

What happens if I don’t offer buyer agent compensation?
Buyers will still see your home. Their written agreement says what they owe their own agent, so they may pay it themselves or ask you for help in their offer. Some buyers with less cash may pass on homes that don’t offer anything.

What does a Collier County seller usually pay at closing?
In Collier County, the seller typically pays the documentary stamp tax on the deed (70 cents per $100 of the price) and the commission, including any buyer-agent compensation or concession you agree to. The owner’s title policy and title fees are usually not a seller cost here.

Thinking about selling? Start with my Naples seller guide, run your numbers on the net proceeds calculator, or call or text me at (239) 289-0749. Se habla español.

Your next step: search every home for sale in Naples, check the latest Naples market report, or if you are thinking of selling, find out what your home is worth and read my guide to selling in Naples.

Buying or selling in Naples?

Ask me anything, in English or Spanish. I answer my own phone.

Magdevys “Maggie” Rodriguez, REALTOR® · Coldwell Banker Realty · 4851 Tamiami Trail N, Suite 100, Naples, FL 34103 · (239) 289-0749 · FL license SL3286877

The property information herein is derived from various sources that may include, but not be limited to, county records and the Multiple Listing Service, and it may include approximations. Although the information is believed to be accurate, it is not warranted and you should not rely upon it without personal verification. Not intended as a solicitation if your property is already listed by another broker. Affiliated real estate agents are independent contractor sales associates, not employees. Coldwell Banker and the Coldwell Banker logos are trademarks of Coldwell Banker Real Estate LLC. The Coldwell Banker® System is comprised of company owned offices which are owned by a subsidiary of Anywhere Advisors LLC and franchised offices which are independently owned and operated. The Coldwell Banker System fully supports the principles of the Fair Housing Act and the Equal Opportunity Act.

© 2026 Magdevys “Maggie” Rodriguez · Coldwell Banker Realty · Equal Housing Opportunity

Magdevys "Maggie" Rodriguez, REALTOR® · Coldwell Banker Realty
4851 Tamiami Trail N, Suite 100, Naples, FL 34103 · (239) 289-0749

Work with Maggie

BUYING OR SELLING IN NAPLES?

Leave your name, number and email and Maggie will reach out personally. No obligation.

No thanks · Se habla español · (239) 289-0749